[ad_1]
In this episode of Jim Cornette’s Drive Thru, Jim Cornette discusses Dave Meltzer’s star ratings for the AEW Full Gear 2024 show. Through his review, Cornette addresses each match at the event, often disagreeing with the ratings given by Meltzer . He analyzes the pace of the fights, noting that several lasted too long, which contributed to diminishing the general excitement. Cornette also questions the logic behind certain ratings, such as those given to matches he considers to have fallen short of expectations or simply too long, compared to others that were more concise and impactful. His speech highlights a divergence of perspectives on the evaluation of performances in wrestling, particularly between technical appreciation and the general entertainment of the public.
THE match evaluations made by Dave Meltzer in his newsletter are often subject to discussion, particularly with regard to the event AEW Full Gear 2024. This pay-per-view attracted a lot of reactions, not only for its fights but also for the ratings given by Meltzer. In this article, we will look at the wrestlers’ performances and the ratings they were given.
Meltzer’s Ratings for AEW Full Gear 2024
At this event, the majority of fights lasted more than 20 minutes, leading to prolonged tense moments and numerous kick-outs. Were the wrestlers able to capture the audience’s attention despite the length of the matches?
The opening match saw Private Party retain the tag team championship titles against Les Kings of the Black Throne and the Acclaimed lasting 13 minutes 22 seconds, receiving a 2.25 star rating. The performance of each other fight, however, has been a matter of debate.
Performance Analysis
Among the notable struggles, the match between mjf et Rodri Strong was rated 3 stars after a duration of 13 minutes 40 seconds. Critics pointed out that if this match had lasted longer, it could have reached a higher level due to better dynamics.
Another notable match was that of Mercedes Monaewho retained the TBS title against Chris Statlander in 19 minutes 24 seconds, receiving 4.5 stars. This bout was praised not only for the quality of the performance but also because it was the longest women’s match in AEW history.
Controversy around Ratings
The rating given to the match between Jay White et Adam Pagewhich lasted 19 minutes 53 seconds for a 4.25 star rating, also divided opinion. Some believe this shows a tendency to over-rate performances, and point out that the fact that a match can result in sections of the audience falling asleep during its duration raises questions about the need for such star weighting.
Finally, the main fight between John Moxley et Orange Cassidy received 4 stars, although critics noted that Moxley’s wrestling style may have failed to capture the essence of the sport. Some people wonder how these ratings truly reflect the quality of wrestling.
Conclusion
Meltzer’s assessments for AEW Full Gear 2024 have undoubtedly sparked intense debates among wrestling fans. Match ratings sometimes seem disconnected from audience expectations, and the question remains: How do these ratings influence how wrestlers and promotions are perceived in today’s wrestling landscape? Time will tell if these trends will continue.